Amazon says email to employees banning TikTok was a mistake
Roughly
five hours after an internal email went out Friday to Amazon employees
telling them to delete the popular video app TikTok from their phones,
the online retailing giant appeared to backtrack, calling the ban a
mistake.
“This morning’s email to some of our employees was sent
in error,” Amazon emailed reporters just before 5 p.m. Eastern time.
“There is no change to our policies right now with regard to TikTok.”
Company spokeswoman Jaci Anderson declined to answer questions about what caused the confounding turnaround or error.
The initial internal email, which was disseminated widely online, told employees to delete TikTok, a video app increasingly popular
with young people but also the focus of intensifying national-security
and geopolitical concerns because of its Chinese ownership. The email
cited the app’s “security risks.”
An Amazon employee who confirmed
receipt of the initial email but was not authorized to speak publicly
had not seen a retraction at the time of Amazon’s backtrack.
Amazon
is the second-largest U.S. private employer after Walmart. Moving
against TikTok could have escalated pressure on the app in a big way,
particularly if other companies did the same. The U.S. military already
bans TikTok on employee phones and the company is subject to a
national-security review of its merger history.
U.S. Secretary of
State Mike Pompeo said this week that the government was “certainly
looking” at banning the app, setting off confused and irritated posts as
well as jokes by TikTok users.
Chinese internet company
ByteDance owns TikTok, which is designed for users outside of China; it
also makes a Chinese version called Douyin. Like YouTube, TikTok relies
on its users for the videos that populate its app. It has a reputation
for fun, goofy videos and is popular with young people, including
millions of Americans.
But critics have cited concerns, including
the possibility of TikTok censoring videos, such as those critical of
the Chinese government, sharing user data with Chinese officials, and
violating kids’ privacy. TikTok has said it doesn’t censor videos based
on topics sensitive to China and it would not give the Chinese
government access to U.S. user data even if asked.
TikTok said
earlier in the day that Amazon did not notify it before sending the
initial email around midday Eastern time Friday. That email read, “The
TikTok app is no longer permitted on mobile devices that access Amazon
email.” To retain mobile access to company email, employees had to
delete the TikTok app by the end of the day.
“We still do not
understand their concerns,” TikTok said at the time, adding that the
company would welcome a dialogue to address Amazon’s issues. A TikTok
spokeswoman declined to comment further Friday evening.
TikTok
has been trying to appease critics in the U.S. and distance itself from
its Chinese roots, but finds itself caught in an increasingly sticky
geopolitical web.
It recently named a new CEO, former Disney executive Kevin Mayer, a move experts said could help it navigate U.S. regulators. And it is stopping operations in Hong Kong
because of a new Chinese national security law that led Facebook,
Google and Twitter to also stop providing user data to Hong Kong
authorities.
Pompeo said the U.S. government remains concerned
about TikTok and referred to the administration’s crackdown on Chinese
telecom firms Huawei and ZTE. Washington has tried to convince allies to
root Huawei out of telecom networks with mixed success. President
Donald Trump has also said he is willing to use Huawei as a bargaining
chip in trade talks. Huawei has denied that it enables spying by the
Chinese government.
A U.S. national-security agency has been reviewing ByteDance’s purchase of TikTok’s precursor, Musical.ly. Meanwhile, privacy groups say TikTok has been violating children’s privacy, even after the Federal Trade Commission fined the company in 2019
for collecting personal information from children without their
parents’ consent. Concerns aren’t limited to the U.S. India this month banned dozens of Chinese apps, including TikTok, citing privacy concerns, amid tensions between the countries.
Amazon may have been concerned about a Chinese-owned app’s access to employee data because the U.S. government says China regularly steals
U.S. intellectual property, said Susan Ariel Aaronson, a professor at
George Washington University and a data governance and national-security
expert.
Part of Amazon’s motivation with the ban, now apparently
reversed, may also have been political, Aaronson said, since Amazon
“doesn’t want to alienate the Trump administration.”
Seattle-based Amazon and its founder, Jeff Bezos, are frequent targets of Trump. Bezos personally owns The Washington Post, which Trump has called “fake news.” Last year, Amazon sued the U.S. government, saying that Trump’s “personal vendetta” against Amazon, Bezos and the Post led it to lose a $10 billion cloud computing contract with the Pentagon to rival Microsoft. Meanwhile, federal regulators as well as Congress are pursuing antitrust investigations at Amazon as well as other tech giants.
AP Business Writer Joseph Pisani contributed to this report.