#9 | Bit-O-Honey: Who doesn't love a Bit-O-Honey? A lot of people, it turns out. Bit-O-Honey, a honey-flavored taffy with almond with reputation for getting stuck in your teeth, first hit store shelves 100 years ago. It came in at No. 9 on Candystore.com's list of worst Halloween candies. (Photo by Spangler Candy Company)